news 05 April 2019

Comment on the recent mandatory registration of working hours

After a period of uncertainty that many companies have gone through, about the obligation, or not, to register the daily working day of their workers, finally last March 12, ROYAL DECREE-LAW 8/2019, of March 8, on urgent measures for social protection and the fight against precarious work during the working day was published in the BOE, where, by modifying article 34 of the Statute of the Workers (hereinafter E.T.), in which this obligation is established, is granted a period of 2 months for businesses to adapt. Accordingly, this measure will enter into force on May 12, 2019

.

RELATED AD:
➡The next Thursday 25 d&# 8217; April, from 9 a.m. to 11 a.m., we will hold a day at the Guild on the new mandatory time registration and on equality between women and men in companies. We will inform you in more detail soon but you can now register at recepcio@gremi-obres.org.


Article 34 of the E.T. covers everything concerning the working day: duration, irregular distribution, breaks between working days, rest periods, working time, work schedule and adaptation of the duration and distribution of the working day in order to reconcile family and work life. In this context, the aforementioned Royal Decree-Law adds in this article a new paragraph 9, with the following wording:

“9. The company shall guarantee the daily recording of the working day, which must include the specific time of start and end of the working day of each worker, without prejudice to the time flexibility established in this article

.

Through collective bargaining or company agreement or, failing that, a decision of the employer after consultation with the legal representatives of the workers in the company, this record of working hours will be organized and documented.

The company shall keep the records referred to in this provision for four years and shall remain at the disposal of workers, their legal representatives and the Labour and Social Security Inspectorate.

Breaking down this new paragraph of Article 34 TEU, the following points emerge:

  • The company must register the daily working day of all its workers, where we emphasize that it must include the start and end time of the day, without us understanding that the signing of a template in which such pre-printed entry and exit hours appear meets such requirements.
  • It should be noted that the rule only refers to the start and end time, but since the purpose is the emergence of overtime, interruptions in the day such as the lunch break or others that are not considered effective working time must be exposed.

    1. As for how the registration system will be carried out (fingerprint, by technological means, with mobile devices, computers, by means of a registration clock, etc...), the standard does not establish any obligation for the use of one system or another. It is transferred to collective bargaining, establishing that it will be in collective agreements where it will be regulated, or failing that, by decision of the employer after consultation with the legal representatives of the workers, in the event that there is such representation in the
    company.

    Given that for the next 12 May 2019, the date on which the day registration comes into force, no reference is made in the vast majority of collective agreements on the use of one means of registration, or another, companies must opt for the system they consider most suitable for their activity, although, in the case of having a Works Council or Personnel Delegates, they must consult beforehand with them the way to carry out Carry out the registration of the day. In any case, and in my opinion, this registration system, whatever the use is chosen, must guarantee the authenticity and integrity of the record, and in those cases that, as a consequence of the particularities of the activity, the registration must be carried out through geolocation systems, respect the right to privacy of individuals, and of the personal and digital data of the worker

    .
  • It establishes the obligation of the company to keep these daily records for a period of four years, and they will remain at the disposal of the workers who request it, the legal representatives of the workers and the Labor and Social Security Inspectorate.
  • There is no monthly delivery obligation. Only if requested, they must be made available to the groups indicated in section.

    Finally, it should be remembered that the obligations that continue, and that should not be seen as a novelty, are those established in article 35.5 of the E.T., where for the purposes of calculating overtime, the working day of each worker will be recorded day by day, and will be totaled in the period fixed for the payment of remuneration, giving a copy of the summary to the worker in the corresponding receipt. On the other hand, in article 12.4 of the ET, which already established the obligation for workers with part-time contracts, to record the working day by day and to total it monthly, in this case, yes, giving the worker a copy, together with the salary receipt, of the summary of all the hours worked each month, both ordinary and supplementary. These monthly summaries of the working day records must be kept for a minimum period of four years

    .

    Although there has been talk of the obligation to record working hours for a long time, from a business point of view this new obligation imposed on companies can lead to problems and reorganization costs. Even more so in a sector such as construction where most of the work is done outside their offices, and often outside the place of residence of the workers themselves. Without forgetting the sector's own mobility, with the movement of its workers to different sites, according to organizational or production needs. Without a desire to be pessimistic, the truth is that creating an efficient system that controls all the cases that occur in the sector and companies, can be complex and expensive, surely resulting in an increase in costs, at already adjusted business margins.

    Finally, and although an unknown has already been cleared, which is the obligation to keep the record, there is still a lot of uncertainty about the many situations that companies will encounter and about the way they will have to carry out the registration of hours. This uncertainty, in the beginning, will surely result in more sanctions for companies, without there really going to be a reduction in precarious work

    .

    Jordi Altafaja Diví
    partner · labor area manager
    BNFIX PICH tax · legal · audit