We recommend 23 March 2016

Compensation for dismissal in contracts prior to the labor reform

If the maximum of 720 days of compensation is reached or exceeded as of February 12, 2012, no compensation is generated for the subsequent period.

In its judgment of 18 February 2016, the Social Chamber of the Supreme Court clarified its doctrine on Transitional Provision 5 of Law 3/2012, of 6 July, which states:

'Compensation for unfair dismissal from contracts entered into before 12 February 2012 shall be calculated at the rate of 45 days of pay per year of service for the time of service preceding that date, [...] and at the rate of 33 days of salary per year of service for the subsequent service time [...]. The resulting indemnification amount may not exceed 720 days of salary, unless the calculation of the compensation for the period prior to 12 February 2012 results in a greater number of days, in which this will be applied as the maximum indemnity amount, without such amount being able to exceed 42 monthly installments, in any case. '


In its previous judgment of 29 September 2014, the Supreme Court — contrary to the criterion applied by the legal operators — considered that if on 12 February 2012 the compensation generated was less than 42 monthly payments, despite exceeding 720 days, compensation continued to be generated for the subsequent period — at the rate of 33 days of salary per year — until the salary was reached Maximum of 42 monthly payments. In this momentous Judgment, the Social Chamber of the Supreme Court has clarified its position regarding compensation for unfair dismissal applicable to contracts concluded before February 12, 2012, unifying doctrine in the terms set out below:

— When periods of service before and after 12 February 2012 are taken into account, the amount of compensation may not exceed 720 days of salary.
— Exceptionally, this maximum of 720 days can be waived if the period prior to 12 February 2012 has already been reported a higher amount.
— If the 720 days of indemnity are exceeded for services prior to February 12, 2012, it will be as reported on that date, without exceeding 42 monthly payments.
— Those who on 12 February 2012 had not reached 720 days continue to report compensation for the subsequent period (at the rate of 33 days per year of service), without being able to exceed 720 days as a whole.
— The calculation of each of the periods (before and after February 12, 2012) is autonomous and is carried out taking into account the years of service, “the periods of less than one year being extended by months” in both cases.

Pich Lawyer-Economists