Rehabilitation Space 22 October 2015

Guillem Carabí: “The buildings of the exhibition bet on a better Barcelona, despite the social and political conditions that prevailed”

Carabí told us about a process of tradition and avant-garde that formed a new architectural panorama grown in the shadow of the socio-economic conditions of the different decades. On the occasion of the end of the exhibition “Modernities. Arquitectura a Barcelona 1924-1975”, organized by the Roca Barcelona Gallery space between 1 September and 17 October. From the Guild we had the opportunity to speak with Guillem Carabí, curator of the exhibition and professor of architecture at UIC.

Carabí expresses his opinion on the need to “keep alive” these historic buildings before they are “museumized”. What would be necessary, as Carabí explains in the interview, is “to rehabilitate, and give them, if necessary, another use; to reform them so that they are part of the life of the city”

.

Guillem Carabí, curator of the exhibition “Modenitats. Architecture in Barcelona 1924-1975: “The buildings in the exhibition bet on a better Barcelona, despite the social and political conditions that prevailed”

12074644_934652619948320_8654629680175799394_n

What is the main idea of the exhibition “Modernities. Architecture in Barcelona 1924-1975”?

The exhibition is the result of the work we have carried out, during two consecutive years, with the students of the subject Composition 4 of the School of Architecture UIC Barcelona. What we have been working on is the idea of “modernity”, understood as the reception, in Barcelona, of that architecture that was played by young architects in the twenties and thirties of the last century, in Europe. Le Corbusier, Gropius, Rietveld, Stam, and other leading names in European architecture advocated an architectural change that made all the sensibility existing until then become classical. Some changes that were discussed at the Modern Architecture Congresses (CIAM), of which one of the greatest promoters was Le Corbusier.

In short, a process that was received in an irregular and heterogeneous way, precisely because of the specific social and political circumstances that occurred in Catalonia during the period from 1924 to 1975. A chronological arc that points to the moment just after the coup d'état of Primo de Rivera, the dismissal of the Catalan governing body, the Mancomunidad, and the extinction of the second dictatorship when its dictator was extinguished. A period that only has six years of democratic government between both dictatorships and the Civil War. A few years, therefore, very difficult to achieve a reception of architectural “modernity”

without stumbling blocks.

What buildings are shown in the exhibition?

What “modernity (s)” does is to show, based on the realization of the models of 26 buildings built in Barcelona of the indicated period, a comparison that, despite the differences, highlights the existence of a kind of “resistance” understood as that ability to modernize architecture from very diverse areas but very often coinciding with what the young architects advocated European. Sometimes, they are buildings that are directly inscribed with modernity, such as the houses of Muntaner d'en Sert street, the Vilaró house by Sixte Illescas, or the pavilion of Radio Barcelona by Rubio i Tudurí. On other occasions they are buildings that, as in the case of the houses of Avenida Gaudín de Mestres i Fossas, or those of Vallhonrat (in L'Hospitalet) by Ramon Puig i Gairalt, live modernity in a quieter way, maintaining certain formalisms of the time but incorporating characteristics of modernity, such as improvement in hygiene and healthiness of the building (insolation of the rooms, etc.) the standardization of the elements, or the incorporation of new technologies

.

There is also a second round. Also shown are 16 models that do what they do is update, from contemporary materials and sensibilities, some of the physical characteristics of the buildings analyzed. Sometimes it is a question of developing an architectural detail, as for example in the building of the Noticiero Universal by Josep M. Ceilings, in others to explain a more abstract concept, such as the ability of a building to expand its space from elements such as balconies

The exhibition has been made possible thanks to the Roca Barcelona Gallery, in collaboration with the School of Architecture UIC Barcelona, which has allowed us to make use of a functional and flexible space where the range of Roca products naturally shares space with exhibitions, presentations, professional meetings and events of interest that energize the socio-cultural offer of Barcelona.

-What characteristics do the buildings shown in the exhibition share?

Obviously such a broad chronological period, such as the selected one, does not allow us to speak of formal characteristics, as the techniques, interests and wills are diverse. But I would say that the examples chosen share, with varying degrees of intensity, an attitude. The attitude to manifest, through architecture, a new sensitivity, changes in the perception of the new role of architecture. To be an activity focused solely on the interests of bourgeois and economic power, to be an activity that is the product of new needs and the notion of service. For example, one of the last buildings to close the exhibition, the Thau School, of Bohigas, Martorell and Mackay, is an example of how a building develops from the modern idea of public education for children, complicity with the topography of the place, and the ability of

a building to foster meeting, exchange and coexistence.

-What significance did these buildings have for the city and its owners?

Without a doubt all of them were remarkable buildings, and they tried to build a better Barcelona. To say a better Barcelona means a city in tune with the new times, despite the social and political conditions that prevailed. All the buildings exhibited are of high architectural quality, but to speak of innovation we should specify what we mean by innovation: technical, social, programmatic, constructive... But we can affirm that, within the possibilities of each commission (public, private, private) they tried to reflect moments of change with the plastic sensitivity

of the moment.

We think that there is not strictly an architecture of the moment. Precisely the title of the exhibition is what it wants to reflect: the existence of many modernity, diverse and varied; not a single, orthodox and univocal idea of modernity. Modernity, as a concept, is of complex definition, and consequently, so was the reception of a European architecture that wanted to be modern and sensitive to the spirit of the times.
12002326_924502900963292_8575071727844639012_n
-Has Barcelona since 1975 maintained the architectural dynamics reflected in these buildings shown in the exhibition?

The chronological limit of 1975 is intended to put in parallel a historical date of our recent history: the extinction of dictatorship and the recovery of democracy. It is, therefore, only an operational frontier. Obviously, buildings of great quality continue to be built in democratic Barcelona: the remodeling of the La Llauna School in Miralles i Pinós, or the velodrome of Horta de Bonell i Rius, among others. It will be, however, with the proximity of the 1992 Olympics, when Barcelona reactivates the construction of service buildings and the improvement of infrastructure (rounds, opening to the sea), and experiences an intense architectural boom

.

-What happened to the buildings shown in the exhibition? Have they kept their splendor?

In general, most retain their use and character. The ones that stand out the most are the oldest, such as the Radio Barcelona building, by Nicolau M. Rubio and Tudurí that is currently in a state of abandonment. Or the Luminor building, by Josep M. Soteras, also in a deplorable state. Others need a good renovation and have only painted the facade, as is the case of the Planells house, by Josep M. Jujol, at the confluence of Sicily with the Diagonal. The Col·legi d'Arquitectes de Catalunya, the work of Xavier Busquets, launched a competition for projects for its rehabilitation, a good way to ensure the quality of the intervention if the competition is well planned. In short, we can find formulas to take care of, intervene and ensure the maintenance of buildings that are part of our architectural heritage.

-Are there specific city council policies to conserve and recycle these buildings? What are usually the solutions that are applied to them to continue using them and prevent them from ending up in ruins?

I do not know the criteria and policies of the consistory towards its heritage, but what is clear is that the maintenance of these pieces of architecture should be a priority. But as in everything, politics, economics, and the will of the people who govern intervene here. And culture cannot be quantified in terms of profitability, as perhaps it can be done in other areas.

In short, what is at stake is that the buildings, as far as possible, remain alive, running. If the new needs imply a change of use, adapt it in the most respectful way possible to the existing one (which does not mean not being able to intervene). But what would be clearer is to avoid museumization. Museumizing a building, in the end, ends up being a kind of embalming that keeps the envelope but lifeless. To rehabilitate it, to give it, if necessary, another use; to reform it, to integrate it back into the life of the city. This is what needs to be done, and surely there is no shortage of proposals and mechanisms to carry it out. You just have to think about it.