Bankruptcy as a quick and effective means of avoiding the personal liability of the administrator
Axel Pàmies Mesegue r, Attorney/Enric Siles Fuentes, Partner//LLOPIS DE AYSA ABOGADOS, counsel to the Civil Guild/Procedural and Mercantile/Banking. (More information about this advice for members)//
Bankruptcy is often considered to be a long and expensive process, so it is not usually considered as an option for those businesses that, for whatever reasons, have ended up becoming insolvent and have ceased their activity. This often results in societies without activity and which according to law should be extinguished do not do so and continue to exist from a legal point of view.
This is a totally undesirable situation, as it may result in the personal responsibility of its managers. In this sense, article 368 of the Capital Companies Law establishes the joint and several liability of the directors for the debts that the company assumes subsequent to the concurrence of a legal cause of dissolution if, within two months from the date of its occurrence, they do not adopt the dissolution agreement or the bankruptcy of the company. The most common legal causes of dissolution in practice are that of having suffered losses that reduce the net worth of the company to an amount less than half of the share capital and that of having ceased to carry out the activity
.For those businesses (whether commercial companies or not) that should declare bankruptcy but do not have sufficient liquidable assets to meet the costs involved, the Consolidated Text of the Bankruptcy Law (TRLC) offers a faster and cheaper formula than that of traditional bankruptcy, but equally satisfactory in order to minimize the risk of liability of the administration body. This formula (Article 470 et seq. of the TRLC) consists of the declaration of the tender with simultaneous conclusion due to insufficient active mass. It is therefore an ideal way in those cases in which the assets of the company are insufficient to meet the expenses derived from the bankruptcy itself (such as the remuneration of the insolvency administrator or the credits generated as a result of the company's activity during the bankruptcy, if any), and will be viable as long as it is not pre-trial visible the filing of reintegration actions (e.g. in case of sale of assets at below-market prices in the two years preceding the tender) or third party liability, nor the rating Guilty of the contest. That is, assumptions that could lead to an increase in the assets of the bankrupt company
.In this type of bankruptcy, the competent Commercial Court is limited to declaring the bankruptcy and, at the same time, concluding it without the need for any further procedure and without the presence of the figure of the Bankruptcy Administrator, since due to the lack of resources of the company or the employer, none of the debts generated within the framework of its activity, the main purpose of the bankruptcy of creditors. It is because of this simplicity and speed in the processing that this procedure is colloquially known as “express contest”.
According to Article 5 of the TRLC, the company or entrepreneur who cannot cope with its debts has the duty to apply for the declaration of bankruptcy within two months from the date on which it would have known or had the duty to know the insolvency situation. However, and due to the strong impact that the health crisis resulting from Covid-19 has had on multiple economic sectors, Decree-Law 5/2021, of March 12, has provided that until December 31, 2021, debtors (natural or legal persons) who are in a state of insolvency will not have the duty to apply for bankruptcy. This measure, although it aims to prevent the bankruptcy and foreseeable closure of the companies most affected by the health crisis, can also be taken advantage of by any company that has become insolvent, regardless of the cause of the insolvency.
This bankruptcy moratorium therefore offers an exceptional opportunity for companies that are engaged in a legal cause of dissolution to assess the desirability of making an orderly liquidation of their assets, in order to then request their declaration in bankruptcy and simultaneous dissolution.
To do this, it is essential to have the advice of professionals who can adequately assess the risk that the contest may be found guilty and avoid carrying out operations that could lead to reintegration actions, before deciding whether it is feasible to opt for the “express contest” application.