We recommend 03 October 2016

Temporary and indefinite workers' compensation

workers' compensation

In recent days, the press has reported on a recent Judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU), in which it is stated that Spanish legislation on temporary contracts would take into account clause 4 of the Framework Agreement dated 18/03/1999 and annexed to Council Directive 1997/70/EC of 28 June 1999 on the ETUC Framework Agreement, UNICE and CEEP (social partners at European level).

Specifically, that judgment answers four questions referred for a preliminary ruling by the Superior Court of Justice of Madrid, concerning the classification of the employment relationship between the parties following the conclusion of several interim contracts, and the payment of compensation as a result of the termination of that employment relationship. Different opinions have been published in the press, which have been more cautious if they come from legal professionals (judges and/or lawyers), or more forceful if they come from trade union representatives or employers'

organizations.

Although we could enter into a legal interpretation of this ruling, we have thought it much more expedient to find out, first, what is the impact of this judgment on our sector. It should be borne in mind that the collective agreement on construction and public works of the province of Barcelona (BOP 27-08-2013), includes in its article 24 compensations for the termination of staff with temporary contracts, which improve the compensation established in the common

legislation.

As can be seen from the accompanying synoptic table, the impact of this judgment on the construction sector is practically nil, since it affects, where appropriate, only contract terminations due to production circumstances (art. 15.1 point (b) of the E.T.) whose duration is between 3 and 6 months (and without forgetting that there is no unanimity as to whether this contractual modality is affected by the aforementioned judgment), since in all other cases, the compensation established in the agreement exceeds the amount that would represent the payment of 20 days' salary per year of service

.

As always, we are at your disposal to attend to any questions or clarifications you need to make on this or any other topic.

Type of Contract Category Annual salary s/. Agreement # Indemnification S/Agreement Compensation S/Judgment of the CJEU
Indemnification Amount Indemnification
Amount
Construction fixed/Internity Ordinary Pawn 19.810,80€ 7% (proportional to the time worked) * 1.386,75€ 20 days/year (proportional to the time worked) 1.085,76€
Officer 1st 23,463,55€ 7% (proportional to the time worked) * 1.642.44€ 1.285,95€
Eventuals/Circumstances of production
Contract duration between 0 and 3 months Ordinary Pawn 19.810,80€ 12 days 651,45€ 271,44€
Officer 1st 23,463,55€ 12 days 771,57€ 321,48€
Contract duration between 3 and 6 months Ordinary Pawn 19.810,80€ 8 days 434.30€ 542,80€
Officer 1st 23,463,55€ 8 days 514,38€ 642,97€
Contract duration > 6 months Ordinary Pawn 19.810,80€ 7% (proportional to the time worked) * 1.386,75€ 1.085,76€
Officer 1st 23,463,55€ 7% (proportional to the time worked) * 1.642.44€ 1.285,95€

* Calculated over 1 year worked

# Salary effective as of 1-01-16 excluding the Extra Salary Plus.

Jordi Altafaja Divi

work area PICH ASSOCIATS